Minnesota old-growth forests: dead and alive

Tornado damage to Townsend Woods, Cannon River, Prairie Creek, Riverbend, and the Cavity Lake Fire

  Lee E. Frelich
  Aug 29, 2006 08:01 PDT 
ENTS:

The August 24 tornado in southern MN had a path 1/2 mile wide and 30 miles
in length and was an F3 with winds 150-200 mph.
I can now confirm, however, that as it plowed across the landscape, it
missed every old growth stand near its path. Townsend woods, with its 250
acres of giant cottonwood trees 15 feet or more in circumference; 70 acre
Townsend Woods, with its 300 year old sugar maple trees; and the Cannon
River, Prairie Creek, and Riverbend stands, old growth maple and basswood
forests that contain the world's only occurrences of the endangered
Minnesota Dwarf Trout Lily, all had close encounters with the tornado and
hurricane-force downbursts, but none were significantly affected.

Isn't there something wrong with this pattern? Aren't tornadoes supposed
to go out of their way to level every last old growth forest remnant?
For those of you into meteorology, radar images of the supcercell and hook
echo, as well as pictures are posted at the National Weather Service
Website: http://www.crh.noaa.gov/mpx/?n=24aug2006

060824_Damage2.jpg (343094 bytes) NWS Photo

Nearly all trees snapped or uprooted in a swath near Lake Emily.

At the other end of Minnesota, unfortunately the Cavity Lake Fire killed
much of the 310 year old stand of red and white pine on Mile's Island in
Seagull Lake. A few small patches remain alive, probably enough to reseed
the rest of the island and perpetuate the genetic heritage of this 5000
year old population. The 200-400 year pine stands on the south half of
ThreeMile Island and around the southwest half of Seagull Lake were
completely exterminated. The ancient cedars of Seagull Lake survived in
some areas, but I have reports that some of the 500-1000 year old trees
were killed by the fire.

Lee