Dunbar Brook, MA Robert Leverett
August 18, 2009

ENTS,

Massachusetts has acres and acres of ordinary woodlands. Beyond the spectacle of autumn foliage and the imagination of the nostalgic, we fall short on "forestscapes", especially in-forest scenes, that are an inspiration for the arts. That's bad news. The good news is that despite the mentioned shortage, exemplary woodlands do exist in Massachusetts. In this communication, I'd like to share one extraordinary place with you. The site is located in Monroe State Forest in northwestern Massachusetts. More specifically, it is the stretch of forest on the lower Dunbar Brook watershed that runs for about a mile and a half along the north-facing slopes of the main Brook, starting from where the brook is dammed.

I hope the following images sufficiently portray what the eye sees when hiking along Dunbar Brook. Capturing the essence of the old growth forest and big trees on film is what I hope to do with the help of friends. In many communications, I have attempted to convey Dunbar's status through statistics. The dimensions and ages of the old and large trees growing in this deep woods setting have been determined and previously reported. For example, we have dated eastern hemlocks to 474 years in age at core height. That suggests at least one 500-year old tree. There are many trees in the 250-year age class, and there is another age class of 140 to 180-year old trees.

Insiders have always recognized that Dunbar excels in big trees. The largest volume hemlock we have modeled in Massachusetts grows there. One of the site's white pines has been climbed and tape-drop-measured to a height of 160.2 feet. Dunbar is also home to the largest single-trunk white pine that we've yet modeled in Massachusetts - a different pine from the tall one just mentioned. Dunbar also boasts what may be the largest forest-grown white ash in all New England. The Rucker index of Monroe State Forest stands at 123.7, third highest in Massachusetts after Mohawk Trail State Forest (136.0) and Ice Glen (128.2). The list of forest and tree superlatives is long, but there is more to Dunbar than just big and old trees. There is an unmistakable deep woods ambience that develops from centuries of natural forest history and from Dunbar's relatively isolated location. This combination has made the forest a place of real significance for those in search of inspiring woodlands. But enough talk. Without further comment, I will let the images do the talking - accompanied by my image narration, of course.

    TanyaRolandOnStripedMaple.jpg
515K View Download

Image#1-TanyaRolandOnStripedMaple.jpg: This image conveys a message. Yes, the downed tree that Roland Blaich and his daughter Tanya are sitting on is a striped maple. Striped maple? Impossible, you say! Not at all. I visited this very tree for years and watched it get larger and larger. But alas, it went down. It now returns its nutrients to the earth that so faithfully nourished it. As Lee Frelich adroitly explained in a past communication over the fall of the height champion red spruce on Greylock, a tree has two jobs, one while standing and one as a decaying log. The old striped maple's forest job has not as yet been completed. This provides a degree of solace for me. However, this big striped maple is not unique. There are other large members of its species in the watershed. Somewhere on the north-facing ridge, there is a striped maple that will challenge the two 66-footers in Mohawk Trail State Forest. In the past, I have measured these gorgeous understory trees in Dunbar to 59 feet in height and 33 inches CBH. There are many in the 24-inch girth class.

  SugarMapleAndGroup.jpg
606K View Download

Image#2-SugarMapleAndGroup.jpg: Dunbar Brook's old growth forest has areas where sugar maple primarily and white ash secondarily dominate. Canopy trees of these two species commonly grow to heights between 100 and 120 feet, and diameters between 30 and 40 inches. American beech once had a significant presence in Dunbar, but beech blight has reduced the species population to a pittance. I once worried about the abundance of white ash as suggestive of past logging operations in what otherwise appeared to be primary forest. Dr. Charles Cogbill, New England ecologist extraordinaire, assured me that on rocky slopes, such as the north-facing slopes above Dunbar Brook, white ash can be fairly abundant from natural disturbances. So, it is not necessary to invoke direct human activities to account for the abundance of ash. This having been said, trees of at least seven species in the 150 to 300-year age range grow among the boulders in the Dunbar forest. In image #2, Roland, Tanya and Monica are seen near one of many large old-growth sugar maples. The big tree appears isolated. In other places, big trees may grow in clusters of 2 or more. The hint of bright light in the upper right-hand corner is from a blowdown of a single forest giant that took a number of lesser trees with it. The result of these blowdowns and subsequent regeneration is a wide distribution of ages. Dunbar's forest is multi-aged. Lee Frelich has walked Dunbar's slopes and has been the primary source of information to me about probable past site disturbances. Lee sees what scientists with lesser field experience have trouble recognizing - the fading imprints of multiple medium-to-large disturbances mixed with countless smaller ones. Maybe Lee could dig into his memory banks and comment on the Dunbar forest. Hopefully, these images will serve as memory joggers for him.

  ForestPrimeval2.jpg
492K View Download

Image#3-ForestPrimeval2.jpg: In places, Dunbar is jungle-like with large old growth emergents thrusting their straight trunks skyward for 100 feet and more through a rich understory of young trees, shrubs, herbs, and ferns. American beech, yellow birch, sugar maple, and white ash dominate the overstory. One sees an occasional basswood or mature red maple, and there are small clusters of hemlocks, but this rich, mesic environment isn't hemlock country, nor red maple country. There is no hint in Dunbar of the dreaded takeover by red maple - a fiction spawned within circles of the timber profession to hoodwink a clueless public into believing that cutting mature forests is needed to thwart an eventual red maple takeover, the very act that will guarantee an increase of red maple. In mature forests like Dunbar's the abundance of red maple is controlled by competition with other species and ecological processes that Lee and other top-line ecologists can more authoritatively speak to.

  BigtoothAspen.jpg
521K View Download

Image#4-BigtoothAspen.jpg: Despite what I am predominantly showing in these boulder field images, much of the Dunbar watershed experienced direct human impact, especially along the lower part of the brook and on the south-facing slopes, but most of the logging occurred fairly long ago. One regenerating stand of hemlocks near the start of the nature trail has a fairly uniform age distribution from 130 to 150 years. There is also the suggestion of an old fire along a steep ridge. Another stretch near the brook has a stand of impressive bigtooth aspens that are now at the far end of their life spans. One on the other side of the brook may soon become the height champion. It was 124 feet the last time I measured it, and it continues to show great vigor. Image#4 shows one of a handful of super bigtooths. Its circumference just makes 8 feet and its height is between 105 and 110 feet. I couldn't get laser returns from the aspen's highest sprigs because of the dense understory. Incidentally, the Indian name of this beautiful tree person is: Tree that eats D-Tapes.

  TanyaAndWhiteAsh.jpg
511K View Download

Image#5-TanyaAndWhiteAsh: This huge forest-grown ash tree is over 14 feet in girth. Depending on where one determines mid-slope to be, CBH values can be obtained between 14.3 and 15.0 feet. My choice gives it a girth of 14.7 feet. The current height of this forest giant is 123.7 feet. It was once over 130, but old age and natural crown loss is taking a toll. It is not long for this earth. In the early 1990s, we cored the Dunbar Ash, and at the time, we counted 258 rings at core height. Today this old gent is at least 275 years young. The big white ash is accessible from the Raycroft Extension trail. It has been the subject of numerous photographs and a painting by artist Heather Lenz.

  ThoreauPine.jpg
548K View Download

Image#6-ThoreauPine.jpg: This is an image of the great Henry David Thoreau pine. I have reported on it many times in the past. Its dimensions are approximately 12.7' x 160.2'. I say approximately, because it now may be above 160.2 feet. It was climbed by Will Blozan and Bob Van Pelt in 2004 and tape-drop-measured. As I recall, Bob modeled the trunk volume to 812 cubes at the time. It is probably at least 830 by now. The Henry David Thoreau pine is one of the truly great white pines in New England. It was the first pine that Jack Sobon and I confirmed to a height of over 150 feet. We used a transit and got 152.4 feet at the time. That was around 1990. The holes in the pine's trunk are relatively new and troublesome to say the least. Tanya took this image of her dad, Monica, and me. Good photo, Tanya. Thanks.

  OldYellowBirch.jpg
646K View Download

Image#7-OldYellowBirch.jpg: Roots of this ancient yellow birch engulf the rock on which it seeded maybe 300 years ago. "Rock-eating" birches are a common sight in the Dunbar forest. A Tolkien-like environment of moss and fern-covered boulders, tangled roots, twisting trunks and limbs, many species of herbs, and a canopy high above create that magic forest elixir that we commonly associate with old growth forests.

  GrandfatherAndGroup.jpg
665K View Download

Image#8-GrandfatherAndGroup.jpg: If total volume is the criteria, the great Grandfather pine is the patrirach of the slopes. It's girth is a solid 14 feet and its height at the end of the growing season is between 144.0 and 144.5 feet. Will Blozan climbed and modeled this huge pine a couple of years ago. Grandfather's volume by now is at least 970 cubic feet - if not more. To cut to the chase, the Grandfather tree is the largest single-trunked white pine in Massachusetts that we have modeled. Elsewhere, it is likely exceeded ...

  SpreadEagleHemlock.jpg
506K View Download


Robert Leverett wrote (August 19, 2009)

Don, Marc, et al:

Here are six more images of Dunbar.

Of late, I have been trying to capture the artistry encountered by the yellow birch-rock interfaces that I see as well as photographically explore the intricate root structures of both small and large birches. The first three images speak to this mission.

Yellow birches do things with their roots that I don't commonly see with the other species in the Berkshire woodlands. I have come to accept the yellow birch as a consummate forest architect. Large birches stay upright in boulder fields for two and sometimes as much as four centuries, all-the-while meeting their challenge in artistically compelling ways. Everyone is entranced who comes face to face with an ancient yellow birch extending its Octopus-like roots around a Volkswagen-sized boulder. What about the old birches is it that is so appealing to us Ents? Ed? Don? Beth? Others?

Naturally, I have to include at least one big tree photo in every submission. Image #4 gives us a peek at a big white pine that has gone nameless. I think Roland first asked me about it. I sheepishly admitted to having previously blown it off because it didn't meet the height criteria I was applying at the time. I've since seen the light. In the image, Roland and Tanya are stretching as far as they can and Monica is filling the remaining gap with a foot and a half span of her hand and forearm. Why this method? I had lost my D-Tape (still stuck in the aspen?) so I couldn't get the big pine's CBH, but it is close to 12.0 feet. In July of 2000, I measured that pine and got 11.6 feet and 125.5 feet in height. My guess is that now it is at least 130 feet tall and 11.9 feet around, possibly 12.0. That would make sense - appealing to the growth rates of other huge field pines in lower Dunbar. Place your bets, folks. Incidentally, there are three other white pines in the vicinity with girths of 12 feet or more. Two are quite tall (Grandfather and Thoreau). The other has lost its top and is short (106.0 feet). I consider 106 feet to be very short for a white pine. Am I spoiled or what?

Image #5 returns to the imaginative assortment of rocks and trees that one encounters throughout the forests in the Deerfield Gorge. Image #6 reinforces the rock-forest theme. The dark monolithic form in the center of the image has the shape of a Native American Manitou stone. I doubt that it served that special purpose because of its location, but I could be wrong.

Those who discover the hidden corners of Dunbar fall in love with the big rocks and the old yellow birches. If one is inclined to believe in woodland spirits, this is the place to make their acquaintance. Although being predominantly of scientific persuasion, I especially enjoy sharing Dunbar with people who relate to the magic of the elfin haunts through their spiritual convictions. These gentle souls have the capacity to experience a level of forest appreciation that broadens my own and gives me pause to contemplate the essence of energy forms other than our own. Regardless of whether one approaches special woodland haunts from a mythological perspective or through solemnly held spiritual beliefs, the potency of the magic of the forests is immeasurably strengthened. At least, that is my observation and personal experience.

Marc,

You've got to see Dunbar. I'd be happy to take you to the big trees, share the high-canopy old growth areas, explore the hidden corners with the tree-rock sculptures, etc. Sound like something you'd like to do? Just say the word. The invitation is open to all Ents.

I'll close by repeating some of Monroe SF's forest and tree superlatives, most of which are contributed by the Dunbar area.

1. Largest single-stemmed white pine modeled in Massachusetts (Grandfather Pine at 970+ cubes),
2. One of two Massachusetts sites to have a tree measured to 160 feet in height (Thoreau Pine at 160.2 feet),
3. Largest forest-grown white ash measured to date in New England (14.7 feet in girth, 123.7 feet in height),
4. Largest eastern hemlock in Massachusetts modeled for trunk volume
4. Third highest Rucker Index in Massachusetts (123.7),
5. One of the three sites in Massachusetts with white ash trees surpassing 130 feet in height (MTSF, Ice Glen, MSF),
6. Second largest yellow birch measured in Massachusetts (13.0 x 98.1),
7. One of only 3 Massachusetts sites with five or more species of trees reaching heights of 120 feet or more,
8. Site of second tallest bigtooth aspen in Massachusetts (124+ feet),
9. One of only 3 locations in Massachusetts with yellow birch measured to heights exceeding 100 feet,
10. One of only 2 sites with striped maple close to 60 feet in height,
11. One of two sites in Massachusetts with 4 or more white pines reaching 12 feet or more in girth,
12. One of a handful of Massachusetts sites with hemlocks confirmed to nearly 500 years in age,

And the list goes on ........

Bob

  BirchRootCluster.jpg
426K View Download

  ArchingBirch.jpg
570K View Download

    SnakingRoot.jpg
372K View Download

  NamelessGiantAndGroup.jpg
477K View Download

    PathWayintheRocks.jpg
518K View Download

  Monolith.jpg
521K View Download

 

Continued at:

http://groups.google.com/group/entstrees/browse_thread/thread/f42baadca5402046?hl=en